The Mysteries of Jacob Colk

It looks like my earlier blog post was a little premature. Jacob Jans Colk may not be my Jacob Kolk after all. I did some searching in the Madison County, Illinois online archives and found something new. I've search the archive for Jacob more than once, but always using the spelling KOLK. However, after coming across Jacob Jans COLK this past week, I decided I should pay more attention to the spelling and did a search for COLK. I came up with an exciting find — I found the naturalization papers for Jacob COLK, who I believe is my Jacob KOLK!

The first paper I found is Jacob's Declaration of his intent to become a citizen of the United States, dated 27 Sep 1875. You can see the complete document on the Madison County Archive site, as well as Jacob's final naturalization paper, but here is a clip of the important information I found in the Declaration.

Here are the important facts I see in this document:

1. Jacob signed his surname with a 'C'; COLK
2. Jacob states he is about 51 years old; that would give us his birth as 23 Sep 1823 to 23 Sep 1824.
3. Jacob was born a subject of the Kingdom of Holland.
4. Jacob immigrated to the United State in 1849, about May, and landed in New York City.
5. Jacob has lived in Madison County, Illinois for the past twenty years, or since September 1855.

How does this compare with what I knew about Jacob before this?

1. I already knew that I can sometimes find Jacob's surname spelled with a 'C'. I didn't realize until now that this was a choice and not a mistake. Until now I'd assumed that someone had misspelled it. I wonder when Jacob decided to drop the 'C' in favor of a 'K'?
2. The 1900 census states Jacob was born Sep 1822. Both the 1870 (age 47) and 1880 (age 57) censuses give ages consistent with a birthdate between 1 Jun 1822 and 31 May 1823. There is a discrepancy of 1-2 years in the naturalization record. I don't know which is most likely to be correct, but the information on the Declaration presumably came directly from Jacob.
3. Jacob's birthplace is listed as Holland on numerous sources including the 1870 and the 1880 census, which agrees with information passed down orally through the generations. (The 1900 census gives his birthplace as Illinois, probably a mistake by the informant or the census taker.)
4. Family legend tells us that Jacob immigrated from Holland but does not tell us when he immigrated. As I've not been able to find Jacob in a US census prior to 1870, I'd assumed that he had not immigrated until the early 1860s. If Jacob gave correct information when he stated that he immigrated from Holland about May 1949, Jans Jacob Colk can not be my Jacob Kolk. (However, I've not yet ruled that out completely.)
5. Obviously, if Jacob lived in Madison County for the twenty years prior to his Declaration in 1875, he immigrated before 1855.

Other things to consider.

1. Jacob may not have been married when he immigrated. If Jacob was 51 when he filled out his Declaration in 1875, he was born in 1823-1824. This mean that when he came to the US in 1849, he would have been 25-26 years old. It would not be unusual for a man to be single at this age in the mid-1840s, meaning Jacob may not yet have been married to Mary Schmidt/Smith. This may explain why his oldest son was not born until 15 years later in 1864.
2. Another possibility is that Jacob was married at the time of his immigration, but not to Mary. His marriage to Mary may have not have been his first marriage. This would also explain why his oldest son was not born until 15 years later in 1864.
3. It is also possible that Jacob had older children, either with a first wife, or with Mary, who were not in the home at the time of the 1870 census. I know that Jacob had a grandson, George, who was the son of a deceased child of Jacob at the time of Jacob's death in 1900. I'd assumed this was his daughter Anna, who disappears after the 1870 census. The grandson used the surname 'Kolk', but I believe it was common for children to adopt the surname of families they lived with.

Things to do next.

1. Look for a marriage record for Jacob and Mary, possible in Madison County, Illinois, but not necessarily.
2. Look for census records for Jacob in 1850 and 1860; Jacob should appear in Madison County, Illinois in 1860. These may list Jacob's wife and older children.
3. Continue to seek passenger records for Jacob Kolk. I've done some preliminary searching in both the Family Search New York Passenger Lists and the Castle Garden site, but I need to look for alternate spellings.
4. Visit the library reference section to look through some of the books authored by Robert Swierenga, including Dutch households in U.S. population censuses, 1850, 1860, 1870 : an alphabetical listing by family heads, and Dutch immigrants in U.S. ship passenger manifests, 1820-1880 : an alphabetical listing by household heads and independent persons.
5. Seek information on the parents of George Kolk, grandson of Jacob. I'll do a separate post on what I know about George Kolk at another time.

Meanwhile, if you have any information on Jacob, or any ideas on how to find Jacob in the 1850 and 1860 census, or the New York Passenger Lists of 1849, PLEASE HELP! You can leave a comment, or contact me!

THANKS!

Is Jacob Jans Colk really Jacob Kolk?

I MAYBE....just maybe....found Jacob Kolk in the New York Passenger Lists! I can't be sure, but there is nothing in the record that would discourage me from believing this is him! Here is bit I found about Jacob in the New York Passengers List database on Family Search.

 Here is what I can see on the ship manifest

• Name: Jacob Jans Colk
• Event Type: Immigration
• Event Date: 1852
• Event Place: New York City, New York, United States
• Gender: Male  
• Age: 29    
• Birth Year (Estimated): 1823  
• Birthplace: Netherlands
• Ship Name: Victoria 

CITATION

"New York Passenger Lists, 1820-1891," database with images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.3.1/TH-1-16946-45639-52?cc=1849782 : accessed 27 January 2016), 112 - 24 Apr 1852-11 May 1852 > image 253 of 837; citing NARA microfilm publication M237 (Washington D.C.: National Archives and Records Administration, n.d.).

So how does this compare to what I already know about Jacob Kolk?

Well, first of all, let's look at the surname. Today I know it is KOLK, with a 'K'. However, this is not the first time I have some across the spelling COLK, with a 'C'. The first census record I've found for Jacob list him as COLK in the 1870 census. Because he is living in the same township with the same family members as he is found in later censuses, I have no problem saying this Jacob is my Jacob KOLK. The surname spelling on the ship manifest is not an issue for me.

I can also look at the birth information. The ship manifest states Jacob is 29 years old and was born in the Netherlands. I have found numerous sources that state my Jacob Kolk was born in Holland, one census record states his birth occurred in Sep 1822. He would have been 20 years old at the time of this sailing in Apr/May 1952; he would not have turned 30 until September. So the birth information is consistent with what I know.

What information did I not have until now? One piece of new information is the full name. I have never had a middle name for Jacob. Whether or not this is my Jacob, and I now have a middle name for him is uncertain.

I also had no year of immigration. I have always assumed that Jacob Jacob came over in the early 1860s, simply because I've been unable to find him in the 1860 census, and I knew the family was in Illinois at the time of birth of his oldest son, James, in Sept 1864. I need to look a little harder for Jacob in the 1860 census, perhaps expanding my search outside of Illinois!

I also notice that there is no Mary Colk/Kolk traveling with Jacob. I have always assumed that Jacob and Mary married before the came to the United States and traveled here together. It makes a pretty picture! However, I also have always wondered how it came to be that the met, as Jacob was born in Holland and Mary was born in Bavaria! I always thought that was a remarkable coincidence. The fact that Mary does not show up on the ship manifest does not necessarily mean they did not meet and marry in Europe. It was not unusually for men to come to the US without their families and send for them later! However, I now have to rethink this. The first born child of Mary and Jacob was James, in 1864. If the Jacob on the ship manifest is indeed my Jacob Kolk, this would mean James was born 12 years after Jacob came to the United States; a long time later if Jacob and Mary were married at the time! It's possible that Mary traveled to the United States separately from Jacob, and did not meet and marry until after they were both here, possibly in the early 1860s. I also need to look for a marriage record for Mary and Joseph, as well as any ship manifest that might indicate Mary traveled here as Mary SCHMIDT!

One other interesting thing I came across is just a few lines above the listing for Jacob Jans COLK. On the same page I see Jans Jans COLK.

There is no indication that they are related or that they were traveling companions. However, there is another KOLK family in Illinois with many of the same names found in the Jacob KOLK family. They settle a little north of here in Whiteside County, IL, but I have always wondered if there is a family connection. I have another avenue to explore!

You can see the complete record here on Family Search.
If you have information to add to this or a correction to make, please leave a comment or contact me!

Thanks to Michael John Neill and his Genealogy Search Tip blog for keeping me updated on genealogy resources. If you don't follow him, you should!